“ Adding new photos from a second visit!!! Food was just as delicious, maybe even better this time. Our waitress was friendly and helpful, drinks were tasty, and the vibes were great. Thankful NYAJ is so close & will continue making it a regular place we visit! ”

“ I came to NYAJ for the first time a few days ago and let me just say I was STUNNED with the great service! Our waitress, Serena, was so so kind to us and was making us laugh all night! What a sweet and lovely woman! And the food was fantastic! My new favorite restaurant! ”

“ I've been to NYAJ's in Watertown and Waltham more times than I can count over the years and it never disappoints. The menu is reliable and they change it up a little on occasion, but my go-to's (burger, pizza, fish and chips) are always there. We wound up in Watertown because I had a birthday coupon burning a hole in my pocket. At 5:30 on a Thursday it was pretty empty, which was perfect as when it is full it can be noisy. Drinks and their delicious bread and flavored oil were served right away by our fantastic waitress. I had a glass of sauvignon blanc and the NYAJ burger with blue cheese, tomato, lettuce, and caramelized onions, with a side of onion strings. Companion #1 had grilled cheese and tomato basil soup; Companion #2 had Mustard Crusted Chicken BLT. My burger was cooked to perfect and the roll sturdy enough to hold the mile-high ingredients but soft enough to easily bite into. The strings were a little, well, stringy, but very tasty. My companions pronounced their meals tasty and took home what they couldn't finish. (Sadly, not enough left on my plate to take home.) NYAJ's is my go-to when I want a reasonably priced meal of American food, a comfortable environment and speedy service. Keep up the good work, NYAJ's! ”

“ Great ambience, decent food and drinks and friendly service sums it up for Not your average Joe's! Stopped by for a late lunch on a Thursday afternoon so it was fairly empty. We ordered both the mocktails and they were good though I liked the one with the ginger better than the pomegranate one. Nachos were a huge portion, jambalaya was a tad too salty but otherwise flavorful, the Smokey Joe's burger was alright kind of greasy. The best part was the chicken dumplings- yummy! Could definitely have had another order of that- everyone enjoyed them very much! Overall nice experience and really glad they survived the pandemic and are thriving. ”

“ Recently, while in the Boston area, I decided to stop at this Not Your Average Joe's for lunch. I got their cheese pizza, which for $10 (small) is not a bad price. The crust was nicely browned and crispy, but the cheese topping itself was a bit bland. I had to add grated parmesan and red pepper flakes to make the pizza taste better. My waiter was nice but not overly friendly. They have locations in many Northeastern states, and I love their large menu with lots of appetizers, salads, burgers, entrees and such. ”

“ We went here before an evening appointment for drinks and apps. Ended up having some beer, cocktails, and food. So good limited number of beer taps and full bar with a page of signature cocktails. Whisky and scotch collection is moderate size and quality with a couple surprises. Food is a big classic to a couple extra special items. Very neuvo American bar-bistro. The place is popular and the food is quality and fresh ingredients. This place is always full of people so people like it. Prices are moderate-high especially for an wannabe olde-fart like me. Stage is friendly and competent. Our bartend, because I prefer siting at the bar, was very busy this evening. Hey manager, you need more staff for a Friday night and train some people up as bar backs. Geez louise! The place feels all modern bistro bar which fits. Bathrooms are clean, pet peeve, and these fold passed. Someone is pay attention. Staff helps each other especially the busy bartender. Kitchen is cranking and even the pizza oven area didn't stop the whole time we're were there. I have been to this place one and off for 25 years, it still a good place to come. Nothing adventurous but I would bring anyone here and be confident on having a good time. ”